Free PDF Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army on the Eve of World War (Modern War Studies), by David M. Glantz
The Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz oftens be fantastic reading book that is understandable. This is why this book Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz ends up being a favorite book to review. Why don't you want become one of them? You can take pleasure in reading Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz while doing various other activities. The visibility of the soft documents of this book Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz is type of obtaining experience easily. It consists of exactly how you should save guide Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz, not in shelves of course. You may wait in your computer device and also device.
Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army on the Eve of World War (Modern War Studies), by David M. Glantz
Free PDF Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army on the Eve of World War (Modern War Studies), by David M. Glantz
Spend your time also for simply couple of minutes to review an e-book Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz Reviewing a book will certainly never reduce as well as lose your time to be ineffective. Checking out, for some individuals come to be a requirement that is to do everyday such as spending time for consuming. Now, what regarding you? Do you like to review an e-book? Now, we will certainly reveal you a brand-new publication entitled Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz that could be a brand-new method to discover the expertise. When reviewing this publication, you could obtain one point to consistently keep in mind in every reading time, even step by action.
This is why we recommend you to always see this web page when you require such book Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz, every book. By online, you could not go to get the book store in your city. By this on-line library, you can locate guide that you actually want to review after for long period of time. This Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz, as one of the suggested readings, tends to remain in soft documents, as all book collections right here. So, you might additionally not await couple of days later on to get as well as review guide Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz.
The soft data suggests that you should visit the web link for downloading and install then save Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz You have possessed guide to read, you have positioned this Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz It is simple as visiting guide shops, is it? After getting this brief explanation, ideally you could download and install one as well as begin to check out Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz This book is really simple to review each time you have the downtime.
It's no any mistakes when others with their phone on their hand, and you're also. The distinction might last on the material to open up Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz When others open up the phone for talking and also chatting all things, you could sometimes open up as well as review the soft documents of the Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz Naturally, it's unless your phone is readily available. You can likewise make or save it in your laptop computer or computer system that alleviates you to read Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army On The Eve Of World War (Modern War Studies), By David M. Glantz.
Germany's surprise attack on June 22, 1941, shocked a Soviet Union woefully unprepared to defend itself. The day before the attack, the Red Army still comprised the world's largest fighting force. But by the end of the year, four and a half million of its soldiers lay dead. This new study, based on formerly classified Soviet archival material and neglected German sources, reveals the truth behind this national catastrophe.
Drawing on evidence never before seen in the West-including combat records of early engagements-David Glantz claims that in 1941 the Red Army was poorly trained, inadequately equipped, ineptly organized, and consequently incapable of engaging in large-scale military campaigns and that both Hitler and Stalin knew it. He provides the most complete and convincing study of why the Soviets almost lost the war that summer, dispelling many of the myths about the Red Army that have persisted since the war and soundly refuting Viktor Suvorov's controversial thesis that Stalin was planning a preemptive strike against Germany.
Stumbling Colossus describes the Red Army's command leadership, mobilization and war planning, intelligence activities, and active and reserve combat formations. It includes the first complete Order of Battle of Soviet forces on the eve of the German attack, documents the strength of Soviet armored forces during the war's initial period, and reproduces the first available texts of actual Soviet war plans. It also provides biographical sketches of Soviet officers and tells how Stalin's purges of the late 1930s left the Red Army leadership almost decimated.
At a time when blame for the war in eastern Europe is being laid with a fallen regime, Glantz's book sets the record straight on the Soviet Union's readiness-and willingness-to fight. Boasting an extensive bibliography of Soviet and German sources, Stumbling Colossus is a convincing study that overshadows recent revisionist history and one that no student of World War II can ignore.
- Sales Rank: #1091793 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Univ Pr of Kansas
- Published on: 1998-05-15
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 8.75" h x 5.75" w x .75" l, 1.14 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 392 pages
- Used Book in Good Condition
Review
"David Glantz is the world's top scholar of the Soviet-German War." --Journal of Military History
"David Glantz is indisputably the West's foremost expert on the subject." --The Atlantic
From the Back Cover
"This book represents the most thorough and intensive examination of the state of the Red Army in 1941 yet to appear. It investigates every aspect of the Soviet military establishment, command, deployment, mobilization, reserves, the Soviet soldier himself, and above all, combat readiness, using Soviet and German archives. Glantz's evidence is unchallengeable, his sources unimpeachable, his conclusion incontestable."--John Erickson, author of The Road to Stalingrad
"Effectively refutes the charge--recently rehabilitated by Viktor Suvorov in Icebreaker--that Stalin was secretly planning an offensive war against Hitler during 1941. With his previous book When Titans Clashed and this latest contribution, David Glantz has established firmly his reputation as the preeminent historian of the Soviet Army."--Mark von Hagen, author of Soldiers in the Proletarian Dictatorship
"An outstanding contribution and a must for any student of the history of the Red Army and the Soviet Union's role in the Second World War."--Malcolm Mackintosh, author of Juggernaut: A History of Soviet Armed Forces
About the Author
David M. Glantz is the author or coauthor of numerous books including To the Gates of Stalingrad: Soviet-German Combat Operations, April-August, 1942; Armageddon in Stalingrad: September-November 1942; When Titans Clashed: How the Red Army Stopped Hitler; The Battle of Kursk; The Battle for Leningrad, 1941-1944; Zhukov's Greatest Defeat: The Red Army's Epic Disaster in Operation Mars, 1942; and Colossus Reborn: The Red Army at War.
Most helpful customer reviews
15 of 19 people found the following review helpful.
The first 6 months of War
By Ryan J. Opel
Stumbling Colossus is a examination of the Red Army on the Eve of Operation Barbarossa. The books examines the Red Army and looks at the prepardeness for war and the prepartations being made for action against the Germans. The book looks at the largest army in the world and takes a pentrating look at the flaws in the system. We see why the Soviets were able to survive the disasters of the begining of the war and the causes behind some of these disasters.
15 of 30 people found the following review helpful.
The author relies too much on Soviet sources. Need updating.
By A Customer
David Glantz has reproduced a lot of Soviet data to show how ill-prepared the Soviet Red Army was in the face of the German Wehrmacht's invasion of the USSR, June 1941. While his statistics are numerous (from Soviet sources), any analysis of the "political-military" aspects of Stalin policy before June 1941 is absent. To his (Glantz's) mind, any present-day Russian scholar who would dare challenge the conventional view that Stalin pursued only a "defencist" policy vis-a-vis Hitler from the Nazi-Soviet agreements to the June '41 invasion is an "anti-Soviet" bigot, to paraphrase his accusations against these reputable, post-Soviet Russian military historians. But Mr. Glantz himself is the one who is being outpaced by new revelations from Soviet archives. These disclosures indicate that Stalin was planning his own offensive strategy against Hitler (which does not excuse, of course, Operation Barbarossa). Second, in his other books as well, Glantz in his shows his lack of acquaintanceship with NEW, post-Communist historiography. Anyone who would care to update himself/herself on this might see recent issues of the journal TRANSITIONS, which tracks in scholarly manner the latest developments -- and books -- in the former East European bloc, including Russia.
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful.
Glantz v Suvorov; neither right nor wrong...
By Philip
Some of my past reviews of Glantz have been unhelpful. I used to agree with Suvorov, now I have a third way.
Glantz is correct. The Red Army in 1941 was woefully badly trained and equipped and in no condition to take on the Wehrmacht. It probably could not have invaded Europe in 1941 without being torn to pieces by the Wehrmacht.
However Suvorov is correct in his general idea that Stalin wanted Europe; he had an espionage and sabotage network second to none to help him, if the Red Army ever got that far. (read 'The Red Orchestra' to find out more about the Soviet spy networks in Germany and Switzerland.)
Stalin wa a chess player. He played chess with lives and territory. He couldn't stop the Wehrmacht invading. What he did was to try to buy time, first with keeping Hitler happy by supplying him with primary resources such as oil, grain, minerals etc. until the last moment. Then he resisted the Wehrmacht by throwing men and machines into the fray to be destroyed. Why? Well he had an 18million man reserve army that the Germans knew nothing about. the Germans really had no idea how big the Soviet military potential really was. Germans did not know about the KV-1 or the T-34.
Stalin knew exactly what the Germans knew about him and what their own situation was because he had spies right in the centre of the German general staff system, the OKW. He knew everything that was going on in Germany and in the Wehrmacht almost before the commanders in the field knew it. In 1941 when he met Roosevelt's aid Hopkins, he was able to tell Hopkins thatthe frontline would stabilise by December around the North to South axis through Moscow. He got the distance right to within about 50 miles. that's how good his information was from his German informants. (information on Hopkins from ' Sunrise at Abadan' by Stewart)
It seems Stalin had decided to trade millions of Red Army lives and large areas of territory in the western Soviet Union in exchange for enormous quantities of lend-lease supplies from America and the UK coming through Iran and Vladivostok. But also he was counting on the fact that the Wehrmacht would gradually wear itself down fighting the Red Army, from July to December. he knew the Wehrmacht was completely unprepared for winter, especially they ferocious Russian winter. He knew if he could draw the Wehrmacht into Russia and into the Russian winter,a bit like the Russians did with Napoleon, he had a good chance of beating it. Stalin knew the Wehrmacht did not have the resources for a long war, or for a slugging match. at the same time the Red Army was learning from the Germans how to fight a modern war, at the cost of millions of lives sacrificed. By the time of Stalingrad,just 16 months into the invasion, the Wehrmacht was truly on it's last legs, as was Hitler, and the Red Army was beginning to look much more like a Soviet version of the Wehrmacht. They had been learning their lessons well.
so much so that from 1944 onwards they really were invading/liberating Europe for the Soviets cause and the communist ideology. They were doing this in a way they couldn't possibly have managed in 1941.
It was thanks to two things that they didn't succeed in getting past Germany. firstly, arguably and controversially, fanatical resistance of the SS divisions slowed down the Red Army advance, together with considerations like weather and logistical problems, so that the Western allies were able to land in Normandy and get to Germany before the Soviets could take the whole of Europe. it was acombination of these circumstances that prevented Stalin in 1945 from completing what he would have liked to have done in 1941 according to Suvorov but did not have the capability to do so. Even the Soviet general Zhukov commented on how the German SS divisions had slowed him downwith their fanatical resistance.
So when it comes down to it, both Glantz and Suvorov are correct, and yet neither seems to have a complete picture. I don't claim to have the complete picture, just a slightly more complete one than either of those two gentlemen.
I would say that Glantz is good to read if you want to know how the Soviet army went from a shambolic mess to the effective war machine that it became, how all that was made possible. I give him three stars for information, but I really can't stand his style, and I still think he is a Soviet/Russian 'patsy'.
Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army on the Eve of World War (Modern War Studies), by David M. Glantz PDF
Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army on the Eve of World War (Modern War Studies), by David M. Glantz EPub
Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army on the Eve of World War (Modern War Studies), by David M. Glantz Doc
Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army on the Eve of World War (Modern War Studies), by David M. Glantz iBooks
Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army on the Eve of World War (Modern War Studies), by David M. Glantz rtf
Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army on the Eve of World War (Modern War Studies), by David M. Glantz Mobipocket
Stumbling Colossus: The Red Army on the Eve of World War (Modern War Studies), by David M. Glantz Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar