PDF Ebook The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith
Currently, reading this incredible The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith will certainly be easier unless you obtain download the soft file here. Just below! By clicking the link to download The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith, you can begin to get guide for your personal. Be the initial proprietor of this soft file book The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Make difference for the others and obtain the initial to progression for The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Present moment!
The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith
PDF Ebook The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith
The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith How a basic suggestion by reading can enhance you to be a successful individual? Checking out The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith is a really simple task. But, exactly how can lots of people be so careless to read? They will certainly choose to spend their free time to chatting or hanging around. When actually, reviewing The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith will certainly offer you a lot more possibilities to be effective finished with the efforts.
Why must be this publication The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith to read? You will never obtain the knowledge as well as encounter without obtaining by on your own there or trying on your own to do it. Hence, reading this publication The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith is needed. You can be fine as well as proper adequate to get exactly how important is reading this The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Also you constantly check out by responsibility, you could support on your own to have reading publication habit. It will certainly be so helpful as well as enjoyable then.
However, exactly how is the way to get this publication The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Still confused? It matters not. You can appreciate reviewing this publication The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith by on the internet or soft data. Simply download and install the publication The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith in the web link provided to see. You will certainly get this The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith by online. After downloading and install, you can save the soft file in your computer or gadget. So, it will relieve you to review this book The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith in specific time or area. It could be not sure to enjoy reading this e-book The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith, due to the fact that you have great deals of task. But, with this soft data, you could enjoy reading in the downtime even in the voids of your tasks in office.
Once again, reviewing practice will certainly consistently offer beneficial perks for you. You might not need to spend sometimes to review guide The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Merely reserved several times in our extra or spare times while having dish or in your office to read. This The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith will reveal you new thing that you can do now. It will certainly assist you to boost the quality of your life. Event it is merely an enjoyable e-book The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, By Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith, you could be happier as well as a lot more fun to take pleasure in reading.
This book has hardback covers.Ex-library,With usual stamps and markings,In fair condition, suitable as a study copy.No dust jacket.
- Sales Rank: #3202181 in Books
- Published on: 1962-12
- Original language: English
- Binding: Hardcover
- 510 pages
Most helpful customer reviews
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful.
"Low lie the fields of Athenry"
By Konrei
"By a lonely prison wall, I heard a young girl calling
'Michael, they have taken you away
For you stole Trevelyan's corn
So the young might see the morn'
Now a prison ship lies waiting in the bay..."
THE GREAT HUNGER is the definitive history of the Irish Potato Famine of 1845-1849. When the Englishwoman Cecil Woodham-Smith published this book in 1962 she was vilified and branded a Communist by the British establishment which had spent the previous 120 years explaining away what is undoubtedly the greatest European famine since antiquity. Estimates of the dead are difficult to quantify. Conservative historians put the number at 1-2 million; others place it closer to 6,000,000. At least another 1.5 million Irish fled their homeland.
Like most disasters, "An Gortha Mor" seems both inevitable and avoidable in retrospect. The Irish population exploded in the first half of the 19th century reaching an official 8.2 million (and an unofficial ten million) just before the Famine. But unlike Britain, which had become heavily industrialized and was moving confidently into the modern and scientific Victorian Era, Ireland was sunk in a morass of poverty and dejection. The average Irish countryman led a life no better than the poorest serfs of Imperial Russia of the day, and the Irish were subject to all manner of legal restrictions, mass unemployment, subsistence agriculture, exploitation by landlords, and eviction at whim from the land and their homes, often just a rude mud cabin. With no education, and few skills other than potato farming, eviction meant almost certain death for husbands, wives and children. Often, they were driven even from the bogs where they'd found shelter after being put out.
The Blight, too, meant certain death for far too many. Eating nothing but potatoes and buttermilk, these most wretched people literally had nothing at all to sustain them after the crop turned into a glutinous, stinking mass of black rot. They died in droves, particularly in the poor west of Ireland, bleak and rocky Connaught. The typhus which followed killed more.
As hideous as all this seems, Cecil Woodham-Smith tells us that the Blight was only one factor in the disaster that overtook the Irish. More insidious was the attitude of the British administration which largely stayed hardset in its laissez-faire attitude, refusing to step in and feed the Irish, refusing to interfere with the free market economy of the day, and worst of all, refusing to grasp that the market economy only works when people have money or skills to trade for products and services. In 1845, Ireland was still a pre-capitalist economy, and the mercantile approach of the British simply could not be applied there; still, the British tried, and blamed their own failure to address the Famine on their convenient perceptions of Irish intransigence and laziness.
Sir Charles Edward Trevelyan may be one of the most hated figures in Ireland even to this day. Effectively the head of British efforts at Famine Relief, Trevelyan was unenamored of the Irish, he was a rock-ribbed capitalist, and, though moral and moralistic to a fault, was also just as singleminded, blind to the suffering of the populace, but fixed on promoting Irish efforts at self-help. He bought a parsimonious 100,000 Pounds Sterling worth of unmilled American corn, and doled it out to provide for the eight million Irish. Amazingly, Trevelyan kept food EXPORTS flowing out of the country at pre-Famine levels throughout (!) Nothing could interfere with trade.
A disciple of the philosopher Thomas Malthus, Trevelyan cast a cold and dispassionate eye over Ireland's circumstances, seeing them as a form of natural population control. At the same time, the British placed the country under virtual martial law, decreeing "seven long years Transportation way on down to Van Diemen's Land" (Tasmania) for minor infractions and acts of desperation (such as stealing corn).
Was this, as many have posited, an organized genocide? Certainly, there were those among the British who despised the Irish to that extent. On the other hand, if this had been an organized killing field, then why did the British do anything at all to help the Irish, little as it was?
Woodham-Smith's tales of people living in bogs, of coffinless mass funerals, of fever patients being abandoned by their terrified relations, of Ireland starving to death, cannot help but touch the reader. The British are presented as less calculating than more stupid, unable to adjust their thought processes to meet the crisis. Conditions were so awful and the Irish were so reduced and brutalized, forced to filthiness, criminal desperation and hair-trigger violence that when the Irish left Ireland (on rotten-bottomed Coffin Ships, like as not), their arrival in American and Canadian ports can be summed up shortly: NO IRISH NEED APPLY. "Paddy Wagons" were so named because they carried Irish miscreants almost exclusively for a time. Miraculously, the Irish rose, and rose all the way to the U.S. Presidency in just three generations.
More than just a history of the Potato Famine, THE GREAT HUNGER is an indictment of the too-common human propensities of blaming the victim, making gestures instead of taking action, and that of ultimately doing nothing. The truth behind every human tragedy can be found in the pages of THE GREAT HUNGER.
This is an essential read.
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful.
Excellent scholarly account
By Old hoosier
Cecil Woodham-Smith's judicious account of the potato famine in Ireland contrasts sharply with the angry tone of Thomas Gallagher's Paddy's Lament. Nevertheless, the two books complement each other very well. Although Woodham-Smith does not neglect the suffering of the Irish people, the main focus of her book is on the British government's response to the famine. She shows how the British administration was constrained by a narrow laissez-faire ideology and an inadequate administrative structure in Ireland, especially in the remote western counties. Although she never oversimplifies, Woodham-Smith patiently compiles a devastating indictment of British policy in Ireland. The main strength of Gallagher's book is his vivid description of life during the famine. He occasionally drifts into fictional methods in order to make his story more personal and immediate. Woodham-Smith is the better historian, but Gallagher packs a larger emotional punch.
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful.
The reason why atrocities happen
By Phillip Kay
How equipped are our governments to deal with emergencies? Supposing a worldwide epidemic, which many scientists forecast, or even a tornado, were to strike, would there be an effective support system with adequate funds to spring immediately into action? Do we want this to happen? Have we learnt anything from the past?
Cecil Woodham-Smith wrote a book in 1962 called The Great Hunger which implicitly asks these question. She had shown how slow the British Government was to learn from the mistakes made in the Irish famine in her book The Reason Why (1953), which details how administrative failure and ignorant leadership were able to destroy the British Army in the Crimea in the 1850s without the Russians having much to do with it. In The Great Hunger Woodham-Smith shows how doctrinaire adherence to laissez faire economic theory, ignorance of conditions in Ireland, hatred of the Irish and unchecked colonialism applied to what was officially part of Britain led to the deaths of more than four million men, women and children in Ireland, and the emigration of two or three million more, many of whom died on their journey, in the period 1845-49. (A note about figures: everything is ambiguous, none more so than statistics. A census of Ireland in the nineteenth century was impossible. Many districts could not be reached because of inadequate roads. The poor were often not counted. During the famine records could not be kept because of administrative breakdown. It is not known accurately what the population of Ireland was at the time of the famine, nor is it known how many died. Stick to official estimates if you want to downplay the tragedy, double those figures if you want to exaggerate it).
It started with bad weather, unseasonably damp and humid, the perfect conditions for the newly arrived potato blight to spread. A simple crop to grow, in Ireland the potato had become the staple food of the nation and was at the mercy of the weather: there had been regular 'shortages' for many years, during which the people went without. Now in 1846 the fungus phytophthora infestans, hitherto unknown in Europe, completely destroyed the Irish potato crop. The bulk of Ireland's conservatively estimated 8 million people (possibly as high as 12-14 million as the western counties were never adumbrated effectively) had no food of any kind. This was just the beginning.
The whole of Europe was affected by an economic recess; food supplies were short across the continent and none available to help Ireland in her hour of need. Following starvation came fever, typhus and others. There was no effective way of dealing with widespread sickness in Ireland, and thousands and then millions died untreated and in some cases unburied. The humid summer was followed by one of the coldest winters on record, and people who had had to sell their clothes to feed their children died of exposure. Complete poverty meant that the Irish had no funds to buy seed for the following spring, widespread lack of education meant they had no knowledge of other crops or efficient cropping methods. In 1847 the weather was good and the crop of potatoes healthy, but only a tiny fraction of what it needed to be to feed the people. Then in 1848 the blight returned, destroying the entire crop for that year.
Ironically, Ireland is a fertile country. During the famine, farm produce which might have fed most of the starving was leaving Ireland for England in a steady stream. As Woodham-Smith explains, this anomaly had its roots in the system of land tenure, which goes back to Elizabethan times. Elizabeth I, Cromwell and many other British leaders followed a policy of dispossessing Irish nobility and awarding their lands to their own followers. Ireland was a plundered country, with no thought taken to integrate it with the rest of the nation or build its economy. Over the centuries the estates were broken down to smaller lots, but the revenues from them were spent in England by absentee landlords. Many of these became impoverished but remained improvident. Soon the only way to attract investment for produce was to sell competitively in foreign markets, hoping to squeeze income for establishments in Britain from the proceeds. Nobody worried about the Irish. They grew the food and sold it to pay their rents. They ate potatoes and lived in hovels. Nobody asked about crop failure.
The key figure in the way the Irish famine was dealt with in Britain was Charles Trevelyan, permanent head of Treasury. Others were Charles Wood, Chancellor of the Exchequer and Lord John Russell, Prime Minister. These men could be said to be responsible for what has been described emotively as genocide in Ireland. Of course they did not create the problem, which had existed for centuries and was a condition of England's conquest of Ireland: it was a powder keg awaiting someone to throw a match.
Trevelyan's contribution was to ignore the problem. Though there was a food shortage throughout Europe in the mid 40s, no planning or forecasts were made for the fragile economy of Ireland. Though the system of poor relief had been shown over many years to be underresourced and impossible to operate, reliance was made on it in the crisis. Throughout the famine Trevelyan was reluctant to send aid to Ireland because that would prohibit market forces from operating and be destructive for the economy (a doctrine of laissez faire Trevelyan rigidly adhered to, as did the government of which he was a part). The fact there was no market, and no economy after 1846, was ignored, along with the stream of reports which detailed the breakdowns in every system of administration in the country. If there was a problem in Ireland, Trevelyan thought, it was the fault of the Irish people, and it was up to them to fix it. The fact that Britain governed Ireland was effectively ignored in the process. Trevelyan was a true bureaucrat, and dealt with many problems merely by calling for further reports on them.
Through convoluted reasoning Trevelyan thought the people responsible for the mass of starving Irish were the landlords, who refused to fund relief funds. He caused rates to be levied, which the bankrupt landlords couldn't pay, and their response was to clear the land, evicting tenants by police and military aid and demolishing their dwellings. The starving were thus forced on the parish and the poorhouses, which were also bankrupt and unable to cope with millions of new applicants for assistance. The British government did provide some slight assistance for poor relief, but as they thought that too was the responsibility of the landlords, they eventually withdrew it. The problem passed from hand to hand, and people died.
Perhaps this is one way tragedies happen. People who don't know what to do do nothing, and ask, What problem? There's no problem!
One of the saddest stories in Woodham-Smith's book is that of the nationalists, the Repeal Association, the Young Ireland party and the revolutionary group lead by Fintan Lalor. With the passing of the great Daniel O'Connell the nationalist movement in Ireland was in the hands of leaders who knew less about the condition of the Irish than the British did. Breathing fiery rhetoric about driving the despoiling English from the land, they strove to organise forces of rebellion from starving men who only gathered in dozens, and mainly for food. But the British, which meant effectively Trevelyan, used this so-called rebellion as a further reason for withholding aid.
Woodham-Smith's book has been criticised as simplifying the problem, and as anti-British. The same complaints have been made against her masterpiece The Reason Why. The Great Hunger tries to be objective. Woodham-Smith uses statistics a lot, refrains from judgmental remarks, quotes from a wide range of existing sources. But she does have a prejudice, against the entropy in large organisations and the tragedies they inflict. She says emigration to Australia was negligible (over one million came to Australia from Ireland), that this was because of the expense of the passage (there were several systems of assisted passage) and that there was no network of Irish to welcome them if they did arrive (there were many earlier Irish migrants, not to mention the convicts) so her information on Australia is deficient. Otherwise her uses of source material is impressive.
Inappropriate administrative procedures, rigid adherence to beliefs inapplicable to the situation encountered, racial prejudice, refusal to see problems arising or deal with them when they arrive ' these methods kill as effectively as the gas chamber. Malthusian economists even forecast the deaths of millions of Irish people and saw it as a reasonable solution to the problem of overpopulation.
Today the world's population is approaching seven billion. Crises involving millions of people are more likely to happen now than they were in 1845 in Ireland. Have the responses we are likely to make learnt from the past?
See all 55 customer reviews...
The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith PDF
The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith EPub
The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Doc
The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith iBooks
The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith rtf
The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Mobipocket
The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Kindle
[F901.Ebook] PDF Ebook The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Doc
[F901.Ebook] PDF Ebook The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Doc
[F901.Ebook] PDF Ebook The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Doc
[F901.Ebook] PDF Ebook The Great Hunger: Ireland, 1845-1849, by Cecil Blanche Fitzgerald Woodham-Smith Doc
